Adirondack Forum

Adirondack Forum (
-   Paddling in the Adirondacks (
-   -   Opinions Needed on Trip Options (

DDinBoston 01-31-2020 04:59 PM

Opinions Needed on Trip Options
Hi everyone - Hoping you guys can offer an opinion (or two) on a few canoe trip options that I'm trying pick between. I'm organizing an annual guys ADK canoe trip. We've been to most of the more known spots, and in some cases repeated a few (nothing wrong with that).

The group is 6-7 guys, coming from Boston and Rochester NY. 4 days, 3 night trip. This year will be mid-July. Love to set up a base camp and do side trips during the day. love fishing, no more than 1 carry, privacy, and nice campsites (lean to would be amazing). Love a hiking trail if possible.

Given that, here's a few spots we either haven't been to, or would consider going again. Curious your thoughts:

1.) Stillwater Reservoir

2.) Follensby Clear/Pollywog Pond (haven't been)

3.) Forked Lake (do you have to book sites on reserveamerica?)

4.) Cedar River Flow (went before under miserable conditions)

I appreciate any input. Anxious to pick a spot and start day dreaming!

LongLaker 01-31-2020 06:37 PM

Follensby Clear/Horseshoe/Polliwog
Long Pond in SRCA.

stripperguy 01-31-2020 08:46 PM

1. Stillwater is big, as are the waves on most days. Plan an extra day in case you get windbound. Lots of cool stuff in the Five Ponds wilderness, but you said just one carry...
I've been a handful of times, it's not for me...Great sunsets and sunrises though.

2. Follensby Clear/Polliwog is not wilderness and often is busy. Much opportunity for side trips.

3. Forked has two sides to it. Eastern side is a state campground with numbered sites, privies, food lockers and Reserve America reservations. Western end has but a few primitive sites, first come first serve. Pretty limited side trips, you could bushwhack up Pilgrim but no views.

4. Cedar River Flow has no carry and some nice primitive sites, but there may be a boat with a motor there. Some interesting side trips up the Cedar River, Little Moose Lake, Buell Brook. You might even see a moose!

My severely biased opinion puts you on the Essex Chain Lakes (one carry but you can wheel it) with a day trip down the Chain Drain to the Rock River.

Or Long Pond in the St Regis Canoe Wilderness area, a short carry and then a few great side trips to Long Pond MT and Pink and Ledges ponds. Very quiet there.

Also consider Lake Lila, absolutely beautiful with an abundance of day trips to Frederica Mt, Shingle Shanty Brook, Harrington and Rainer brooks, the old train station, and some of the Beaver River. 0.3 mile carry. Very quiet there too...

TrailBlaser 01-31-2020 09:10 PM

Round Lake is another option. It connects to Little Tupper so you can split time between the two locations. Easy put-in/take out as well.

chairrock 02-01-2020 12:21 PM

Oswegatchie from Inlet upstream to a nice base camp. Day paddle to High Falls and points beyond. Lots of hiking trails leading to backcountry ponds.

TrailBlaser 02-01-2020 08:13 PM


Originally Posted by chairrock (Post 280159)
Oswegatchie from Inlet upstream to a nice base camp. Day paddle to High Falls and points beyond. Lots of hiking trails leading to backcountry ponds.

I second this suggestion. I make a trip up the river almost every year. I try to go in high water so I can travel easier above the falls. I like the area around the Robinson River.

madison 02-08-2020 03:43 PM

I second the Little Tupper/Round Lake suggestion. No carries, lots of free/first come sites, and a few nice options for day trips. head out as early as possible, though, because the winds from the west/southwest can be strong and kick up some waves. Rock Pond is a great day trip from Little Tupper.

Cranberry Lake is another favorite of mine, although it can also get windy. And there are motorboats, but it's not as bad as some lakes like Raquette, the Fulton Chain, or Lake George. The bays and inlets make great day trips and are away from the boat traffic. Joe Indian Island has great, well spaced campsites.

Great bass fishing for both these locations also.

Buckladd 02-11-2020 10:41 AM

Getting back to the poster's original question regarding places he hasn't been; as stated above, Stillwater can be a windy hell, but otherwise it's awesomel. On Forked, there is much to explore and you can always carry over to Raquette for a side adventure. There are campsites on the west end of Forked that I believe you don't have to register for.

FB-Clear/Pollywog - As stated, quite crowded, but good fishing on Horshoe and lots of loons. Pre-summer, mid-week might work

Cedar River: Love it, especially down river to the lean-to. I've always wanted to go further but the water has never been high enough. I saw a big moose in there a few years ago.

TrailBlaser 02-12-2020 07:08 AM

I love the Cedar River, paddling through the grasses is something special.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:00 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, vBulletin Solutions Inc.