Adirondack Forum

Adirondack Forum (http://www.adkforum.com/index.php)
-   Hunting and Fishing in the Adirondacks (http://www.adkforum.com/forumdisplay.php?f=64)
-   -   Would You Be Offended Or Not? (http://www.adkforum.com/showthread.php?t=27158)

NHtroutster 07-13-2019 12:56 AM

Would You Be Offended Or Not?
 
1 Attachment(s)
I had an interesting interaction tonight worth sharing for comment...

Like many of the avid anglers on this forum, I'm a big believer in strictly adhering to fishing rules and regulations--both because I love trout fishing and the lessons it teaches my sons, and my profession is in natural resources management. Over the past several years I've attended several public hearings complaining about the lack of adequate DEC enforcement, though I'm fully aware that state budgets and priorities aren't where they should be to protect our beautiful ADK gifts. So on an outing tonight with one of my sons when I was approached by a Encon officer (notably on a heavily pressured catch-and-release public fishing stream where in 10 years I've never seen one before), I was more than happy to show him our licenses and permit a search of our persons and truck to be sure we weren't keeping any fish. While the officer was a consummate professional during the interaction, I must admit I was surprised when he told me he'd received a report that a person matching my exact description was keeping fish. While of course no violations were found and our conversation (again) was very cordial, I can't help but to feel more than irked that someone could mistake careful CPR fishing (as per the picture) with illegally harvesting fish in a catch-and-release fishing stream. The officer shared his business card with me and I've already sent him a note to thank him for his service, but what say you all?? Would you all be po'd to have this kind of interaction?

Thanks, NHtroutster

Lucky13 07-13-2019 09:09 AM

I'd be more concerned about the person who called this in. They could have been innocently mistaken, or they may have a grudge against fishers, or out of staters. The ECO's get a lot of grief if they don't respond to complaints, he was just doing his job. And you are helping him with this because one of the best ways for keeping people following the rules is to let them know there can be penalties for breaking it, and if you keep spreading the tale of the ECO at CPR Crick, poachers who frequent the place for nefarious purposes will at least get more tired necks from watching over their shoulders, but maybe they go elsewhere. We have a No Kill stretch on a stream outside Rochester, and I've never seen an ECO there, but I have heard stories, and when I have encountered people bait fishing, after politely and non-confrontationally informing them of the "rules" (and there are signs, but reading is dead!), I used to go drop a dime (or a quarter, or now a half dollar if you could find a pay-phone) and now I just use the cell phone call the TIPP line. Since this stretch became C+R, baitfishing and keeping fish has dropped to almost nothing, and I think some of that is because people called, and the ECO's responded.

mgc 07-13-2019 10:42 AM

ECO's are spread thinly but they are out there and they are more dialed in than the average Joe realizes. They do rely on information from the tiplines but they also have a pretty good idea of the areas that they need to keep an eye on. In the Rochester area they spend a great deal of time managing the Genesee River violations but they also keep a pretty close eye on the areas surrounding. I have all of the Monroe and Orleans County ECO's in my phone contacts list. They take calls and return messages if you contact them directly. All of their contact information (statewide) is listed in the State Laws and Regs that you can pick up when you buy a license. They are also listed on the DEC site. They are a hunter and fisherman's friend...unless you are doing something shady.

DuctTape 07-13-2019 10:53 AM

I see the ECOs semi-regularly in the Braddock Bay and nearby environs.

EagleEd 07-13-2019 11:23 AM

Why even mention being po'd or not when the officier was just doing his/her job. Each one I have met has been very professional in addressing me and I have replied in the same manner.

Eagle Ed

NHtroutster 07-13-2019 11:55 AM

I was po'd for someone calling in on me... As I said, no grief at all with the ECO, and we had a great discussion. But if someone/anyone was actually watching my son and I there's no way they'd mistake us for taking fish. Honest mistake or grudge as Lucky suggested might be accurate, but it doesn't make me feel better about it. All of you know that sense of euphoria trout fishing brings at the end of an outing, whether successful or not. And last night to have it end with my integrity being questioned zapped that euphoria. That's all I'm saying.

gmorin71 07-13-2019 12:22 PM

How do you know it was you that the guy saw? I k how the eco said it was someone that matched your description but that description was probably very generic. He very well may have called in someone else and the eco came to you first. With the eco being friendly i dont think theres a reason to be upset. In fact, I'd be happy that theres some enforcement going on

NHtroutster 07-13-2019 12:55 PM

ECO said "red hat, red shirt, black truck", yeah that was me. Again, we had a 10 minute discussion on enforcement issues and I've since emailed him with a thank you so all is good there. I'll get over it I'm sure.

Haven't even been able to point out that I've NEVER caught a brookie in that location, so for my son to land this beaute on his first cast was pretty exciting. That's the memory I'll choose to focus on I suppose.

Edb 46 er 07-13-2019 12:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NHtroutster (Post 276693)
I had an interesting interaction tonight worth sharing for comment...

Like many of the avid anglers on this forum, I'm a big believer in strictly adhering to fishing rules and regulations--both because I love trout fishing and the lessons it teaches my sons, and my profession is in natural resources management. Over the past several years I've attended several public hearings complaining about the lack of adequate DEC enforcement, though I'm fully aware that state budgets and priorities aren't where they should be to protect our beautiful ADK gifts. So on an outing tonight with one of my sons when I was approached by a Encon officer (notably on a heavily pressured catch-and-release public fishing stream where in 10 years I've never seen one before), I was more than happy to show him our licenses and permit a search of our persons and truck to be sure we weren't keeping any fish. While the officer was a consummate professional during the interaction, I must admit I was surprised when he told me he'd received a report that a person matching my exact description was keeping fish. While of course no violations were found and our conversation (again) was very cordial, I can't help but to feel more than irked that someone could mistake careful CPR fishing (as per the picture) with illegally harvesting fish in a catch-and-release fishing stream. The officer shared his business card with me and I've already sent him a note to thank him for his service, but what say you all?? Would you all be po'd to have this kind of interaction?

Thanks, NHtroutster

I had a similar experience while on my way out to my vehicle, I had a float tube, waders, and rod in hand when approached by a Forest Ranger. He was parked directly behind my vehicle waiting for my appearance. Looking upset about something he grudgingly asked for my fishing license. I complied with no argument. He said, thank you and went on his way. I never saw him again in the area and that was the first time I ever did see him.
So, not sure what was happening, but I believe he was looking to see if everything was okay.

vtflyfish 07-13-2019 02:45 PM

NH, I know it's easy to take it personally. Rise above it. It's worth putting up with the odd encounter for some obvious enforcement.

It's great to see you out fishing with your son. There's no better way to spend your time!

Buckladd 07-13-2019 04:03 PM

Don't let it bother you, but I'd be curious of the intentions of the one who reported you. I was turkey hunting this past spring and had a state trooper show up at my spot. Earlier, a white vehicle had gone by and tooted the horn. I thought it was someone I knew. The officer said someone reported "a guy with a gun putting something in a bag." Actually, I was taking decoys out. The officer knew it was turkey season, but had to check anyway. Our meeting was very cordial. Later in the season that car went by and tooted again, all the way down the road. I think it's an anti trying to mess with my hunt. I don't want to cause trouble for the landowner, so I backed off any type of harassment pursuit. Anyway, I'm wondering if you have the same type of thing going on?

mgc 07-13-2019 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buckladd (Post 276705)
Don't let it bother you, but I'd be curious of the intentions of the one who reported you. I was turkey hunting this past spring and had a state trooper show up at my spot. Earlier, a white vehicle had gone by and tooted the horn. I thought it was someone I knew. The officer said someone reported "a guy with a gun putting something in a bag." Actually, I was taking decoys out. The officer knew it was turkey season, but had to check anyway. Our meeting was very cordial. Later in the season that car went by and tooted again, all the way down the road. I think it's an anti trying to mess with my hunt. I don't want to cause trouble for the landowner, so I backed off any type of harassment pursuit. Anyway, I'm wondering if you have the same type of thing going on?

So one of the interesting things that the ECO's enforce is someone interfering with a legal hunt. The honker could end up with a ticket if you can catch them in the act. One of the local ECO's tells of giving a ticket to a woman that came out of her house and started banging pots and pans to scare birds away from a legal spread... another about writing a host of tickets to someone who harassed some waterfowlers with a jetski. In both cases the offender did not like the proximity (legal) of the waterfowlers and decided to stink up the hunt....

If an ECO checks my tags, checks me for flotation devices, checks the plugs in my gun or stops me for any other reason it pleases me that he's out there doing his job. I enjoy the opportunity to meet these guys outside of my classes. Chill.

Buckladd 07-13-2019 10:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mgc (Post 276706)
So one of the interesting things that the ECO's enforce is someone interfering with a legal hunt. The honker could end up with a ticket if you can catch them in the act. .

Yup, I'm fully aware of hunter/angler harassment laws, which the trooper and I discussed. But as I said, I don't want to get the landowner, who is a friend, involved in some sort of neighborhood squabble. I'm lucky to have this spot. But I'd love to give that person an earful, especially the fact that I bagged a nice tom there despite the honking.

ADKpikebuster 07-17-2019 03:46 PM

Fact be known that illegal fish taste better

Glen 07-20-2019 11:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADKpikebuster (Post 276735)
Fact be known that illegal fish taste better

Only when washed down with a Busch Light....

ADKpikebuster 07-20-2019 09:14 PM

I drink the beer, I catch the fish, I stop, I pee and I repeat

wildbrookies 07-20-2019 09:43 PM

Well said Adkpike!!! HaHaHaHa!!

chaser 07-21-2019 09:25 PM

Damn Piker is a pro!!!

chaser 07-21-2019 09:28 PM

Not to get off track, why get offended, he's got a job to do regardless if there was a complaint or not and thank heavans he is as under staffed as they are. As long as you're toeing the line, what's it matter.

vtflyfish 07-21-2019 11:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADKpikebuster (Post 276792)
I drink the beer, I catch the fish, I stop, I pee and I repeat

Pikebuster,

Last I knew your actual behavior was:"I drink the beer, I pee and I re-pee." The fish never seemed to care or notice.:boozing::boozing::boozing::rolling:


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:08 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.